National Journal’s Report on Missing Workers Misstates History of Labor Force … – NewsBusters – News Journal Blogs

Give metropolis Cook at assign for a mostly well-written though somewhat credulous report (“Forget the Unemployment Rate: The Alarming Stat Is the Number of ‘Missing Workers’”) on the unexampled pledge of the jillions of adults who hit dropped discover of the fag force.

But in discussing the “glaring caveat” in Friday’s job report from the government, videlicet that “the ‘labor obligate status rate’ held stabilize in Apr at 63.3 percent—the minimal take since 1979,” she uncomprehensible a field maker of the uprise in the evaluate to a achievement take in the late-1990s. She also mitt readers otherwise unmindful of the actualised story with the notion that the evaluate has been “on a sloping decline” since then, which is only not the case.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Here is the germane excerpt:

Since the move of 2007, the proportionality of Americans in the fag mart has dropped from 66.4 proportionality to 63.3 percent. In the 1970s and 1980s, the sort of employed Americans grew—because of the hammy process in women retentive jobs correct of the home.

The proportionality of Americans in the fag mart peaked in the New 1990s with the palmy Clinton-era economy. Remember every of the life before the school eruct burst? Since then, the fag obligate status evaluate has been on a sloping decline.

A reverend unmindful of the statistic’s story and its honor of modification would probable conceive that its proportionality was farther higher during test eld of the preceding decade. After every if a three-point, six-year modify is conception of an coverall “gradual” trend, then the fag obligate status evaluate staleness hit been artefact above 70 proportionality during the New 1990s, right?

Wrong, as a interpret of that datum from the government’s Bureau of Labor Statistics shows us:


The seasonally keyed extreme of 67.3 proportionality actually occurred during the prototypal quaternary months of 2000, gradually declined to 66.1 proportionality in August 2003. During the incoming 5-1/2 years, the evaluate essentially held stabilize until substantially after the 66.4 proportionality Jan 2007 extreme Cook cited, never feat beneath 65.8 proportionality or above 66.4 proportionality until Feb 2009. That’s the prototypal flooded period after Barack Obama’s start and more than a assemblage after the National Bureau of Economic Research claims the ceding began. The atomlike “gradual change” during that instance was 0.00455 proportionality per period (0.3 proportionality separated by 66 months). The evaluate in August 2008 was the aforementioned 66.1 proportionality seen in August 2003.

Combined, the unnoticed 5-1/2 eld of the rate’s unchangeability during the Dubya 43 presidency, Cook’s meaning to “the palmy Clinton-era economy,” her unfortunate to specifically advert the Clinton-era extreme so readers could hit comely context, and her unfortunate to study Dubya 43 by study provide absent either a clean turn of sloppinness or bias. I angle towards the latter.

The credulous portions of Cook’s impact hit to do with her belief that there are solutions to the difficulty supported on more polity spending, a matter which I haw intend to in broader modify in added post.

Cross-posted at


swatches1 Art Journal pages created from Kelly Kilmer class Swatches.

All Rights Reserved

National Journal’s Report on Missing Workers Misstates History of Labor Force … – NewsBusters

This entry was posted in . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a reply

Other Popular Posts in this Blog:

Pageviews past week